Pappy's Sauce for Sissies. Even Tough Guys can have a hard time with a little spice. That's why there is Baby Food and Pappy's Sauce for Sissies. Honest Folks, I couldn't Make it any milder and still live with myself. Tomato Sauce, Sugar, Vinegar, Fresh Garlic, Fresh Onion, Chile Pepper, Paprika, Modified Food Starch, Natural Hickory Flavoring, Worcestershire Sauce, Black Pepper, Spices, Lemon Powder, (Corn Syrup, Lemon Juice with added Lemon Oil), Citric Acid. 12.7oz.